Professional Home Staging and Photography Blog: Esko Kiuru

White House solicits ideas for mortgage finance reform - Let's give them some

NW house, Las Vegas, NVThe home loan market has evolved over the decades into a colossal and thoroughly complicated system that is so hard to get one's arms around with any authority. One of the latest additions to it were the otherworldly subprime mortgages and their subsequent securitization that eventually grew so tricky that few, if anyone for that matter, can today decipher what they actually look like. A fair part of the blame for the current real estate collapse can be squarely allocated to this out-of-control creativity.

The White House put forth seven questions for public comment in its quest to overhaul the mortgage finance system and it has to be commended for seeking ideas from the trenches. A bunch of sharp minds earn their living in there and can truly bring valuable mortgage input to the table. How much do their opinions matter at the end of the day is a different argument. Anyhow, these questions are rather academic-sounding - perhaps shaped by some Harvard PhDs on a mission - and cover a wide range of territory, essentially the whole industry, it seems. Does the entire system need to be overhauled? Not really. Many sectors in it work rather well, maybe needing just some updating to meet today's rapidly-shifting mortgage landscape.

Let's give it a go then.

Streamlining the present finance regulatory structure would sharpen things up a great deal. If done with foresight and minimum political interference it could become a durable bedrock on which to anchor the mortgage and real estate markets for a long and successful run. 

Currently there appear to be somewhere close to a dozen federal regulatory agencies tasked to keep the system running as designed. It largely failed during the years leading up to the housing market climax. The structure is just too fragmented to be efficient. Too many players are involved in monitoring what goes on there. Often agency responsibilities overlap, leading to destructive turf wars and situations where nobody reacts because everybody figured the other departments were going to cover it. This is not the way to run a store as critical to the economy as it is.  

If anything, the present mortgage regulatory regime should be merged into no more than six existing agencies. It's much easier to control anything when the moving parts are under one roof, or just a few roofs. Along these lines, instead of eliminating Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac - as some inside and outside government are clamoring - they could be consolidated into one GSE, or Government Sponsored Enterprise. Their current mortgage playbooks are essentially copies of one another, so it could be done without too much grief.

This input covers parts of several questions put forth by the Obama Administration. Its theme is simplicity. Something rather far-reaching needs to be done to prevent future mortgage and housing collapses of this magnitude from happening again, whether Wall Street likes it or not.



Provided by: 

Esko Kiuru
Mortgage, real estate and apartment industry analyst - syndicated mortgage, housing and property management blog
My cell: 702-499-1006

Comment balloon 8 commentsEsko Kiuru • April 16 2010 01:27PM
White House solicits ideas for mortgage finance reform - Let's give…
The home loan market has evolved over the decades into a colossal and thoroughly complicated system that is so hard to get one's arms around with any authority. One of the latest additions to it were the otherworldly subprime mortgages and their… more
FHA takes risk management seriously
As FHA's market share has soared over the past few years, thanks to the vacuum left by conventional mortgage lenders whose fortunes have suffered terrible setbacks in the ongoing real estate calamity. But it hasn't escaped the anger of the sinking… more
Delinquent mortgage borrowers with PMI staging fragile comeback
Some good news are starting to sneak into the devastated real estate market from far-off directions. They may not mean all that much in the conventional big picture that usually chews over topics like foreclosures, short sales, home price drops and… more
Mortgage giant BofA to lower principal for qualified HAMP borrowers
The housing market meltdown seems to be truly making life miserable for Bank of America. As things started unraveling in the residential real estate sector and pushed countless mortgage lenders to either bankruptcy or to the brink of one, BofA… more
Mortgage fraud declining amid tightening underwriting criteria
When the notorious housing bubble was forming some years ago a lot of factors were aiding and abetting its run to those dizzying, unsustainable heights. One of them was mortgage fraud. Banks were so busy crafting new and glitzy home loan products… more
Will mortgage rates head higher soon? A tough one
The real estate market has been meandering along with little purpose for a long time, trying urgently to locate firm ground anywhere from which to launch something resembling a rebound. That it is in a position like this at all it can thank the… more
Mortgage industry faces changes by new financial regulation bill
The home loan and real estate markets have been anxiously waiting for fresh initiatives from Washington to address the many shortcomings that led to the recent bust. For a time it looked as if not much was going to happen thanks to the fierce… more
Real estate transactions may be burdened by private transfer fees
The present housing and mortgage overload is by some estimates only halfway through its painful cycle, still desperately looking for traction to solve high mortgage foreclosure numbers, underwater homeowners by the millions, home loan providers… more
HUD steps up mortgage modification scam enforcement - Las Vegas…
Home loan scams are really part of the real estate landscape in any market, but generally speaking affecting only a small percentage of consumers. Now, however, things are very different. This housing and mortgage meltdown ranks right up there… more
Mortgage lenders in HUD's crosshairs over high FHA insurance claims
FHA-insured home loans have carved a large chunk of the market during this prolonged housing meltdown. Conventional mortgage lenders have withdrawn in large numbers into the shadows to get TLC from the government just to be able to survive. Many… more